Investigations on social insults for defamation must continue, with the aggravating circumstance of the discrimination of racial hatred, against Liliana segre. This was decided by the magistrate of Milan Alberto Carboni, who ordered the Prosecutor to identify with new investigations 86 Account, essentially accepting the request to move forward with the procedure made by the senator for life, through the lawyer Vincenzo Saponara. The same judge ordered the registration of nine people who had not been investigated and the compulsory charge for another seven. The prosecutor had asked for the storage for 17 positions. Once the accusation against Chef Rubio has been archived.
The investigating judge in its provision, filed this morning, orders the prosecutor of Milan Nicola Rossato, who had asked for the storage for 17 suspects, to formulate the forced charge, namely the decree of summons aimed at trial, for seven people (not chef Rubio whose position is archived). In addition, he orders the registration with new investigations on nine other people, never investigated before, including Nicola Barreca, who in 2023 appeared as the city secretary of the League in Reggio Calabria. In addition, the same judge ordered that “new investigations are carried out (request for electronic data acquisition, OSINT investigations and personal data present in the social profiles) aimed at identifying the following social profiles” and lists 86 in total. “In 90 percent of cases the insults he receives are Nazis, this is the point, they are not insults at his venerable age or his political positions, but they are Nazi insults”, explained the lawyer Vicenzo Saponara, a senator’s lawyer and survived the Shoah. A lawyer who on March 27 had discussed the opposition to the request of the Rossato prosecutor in front of the investigating judge to store the position of 17 alleged haters of the Senator. Opposition that had also been on the application that concerned other verbal aggressions on social media, contested “to unknown persons”, because not identified by the prosecutor. The prosecutor in January had closed the investigations for the request for indictment only against twelve people, including no Vax and Pro Pal, also residing abroad, accused of defamation and online threats, with the aggravating circumstance of the discrimination of racial hatred. He had deposited a table containing 246 social accounts and the related insults and offenses aimed at surviving the Shoah.
“From Chef Rubio only harsh words but not offended to segre”
«The phrases reported, however rough, represent a argued manifestation of the author’s thoughts regarding a politically sensitive theme. The terms used are continents and do not resolve in offensive expressions ». The investigating judge of Milan Alberto Carboni writes in the part of his measure, on the social insults to Liliana Segre, with which he has The accusation of defamation aggravated by racial hatred for Chef Rubio for some of his posts has been archived. The position of Gabriele Rubini, also well -known TV personality, is one of the ten archived by the judge. In the various posts on the theme of the Palestinian cause Rubini wrote, among other things, “condemn Zionism” and phrases with a “form of harsh criticism on politically sensitive issues”. And he also used expressions of “bad taste”, which however do not take “defamatory value”. In the 75 -page order, the judge reports a maxi table with all 246 messages shown in the complaints of the senator for life. Table in which the “nickname” of the account are listed one by one, the possible “identification” of the author, the “content of the lawsuit” and then the “decision” of the investigating judge on each individual message posted.
In relation to the investigations to get to the identification of the various profiles, the investigating judge explains that “Facebook and Instagram have communicated that they had taken care of the requests and responded only on a discretionary basis.” Google has “communicated that the user’s right to have opinions and spread free ideas from interference of the public authority prevails over the legitimate interest of the police in investigations”. Twitter replied “on a discretionary basis considering that it can communicate the data in possession, both of registration and connection, only for some of the required accounts”. And Telegram “did not provide any response”. The investigating judge, however, clarifies that “in most cases Facebook users”, but also of the former Twitter and Instagram, “record the profile with their real name and insert numerous personal information” and, therefore, “the possibility of identifying the authors of the posts is realistic”. From here the new investigations, which have not been carried out before and which have now been ordered to the prosecutor. As regards a post published in 2022 by Nicola Barreca – Secretary – At the time of the League in Reggio Calabria and which must now be registered in the register of suspects – the investigating judge talks about Un “message” which “is reduced to free shifts and derision expressions” also on the “painful practice of shaving the head of the women who were interned in the concentration camps”. A “diles” of Segre “through the physical derision and the exploitation of its painful past”.