Messina, expensive fuel: back and forth on the rejected motion

John

By John

Choose us on:

Google Discover

Google logo
Preferred Sources

Public transport service in Messina

New clash in the city council. The majority rejected the motion of the mayor’s Scurria group – supported by the entire opposition – which, due to the high cost of fuel, proposed making public transport in the city free for a month during the Christmas period. «It is a shame – declares Marcello Scurria – that we are unable to understand the value of a concrete measure to support citizens, especially at a time when families, workers and traders have to deal with the continuous increase in the cost of living». The councilor, together with Pippo Capurro and Simona Contestabile, recalls the data obtained from the latest balance sheet of ATM, which «recorded approximately 11 million euros in profits and which in the last five years would have paid approximately 2 million and 400 thousand euros in taxes. A reality that collects resources from the people of Messina through parking and the tow truck service. Faced with these numbers, the majority has chosen to take refuge behind unfounded arguments. It is not a technical position, but a precise political choice, which the people of Messina must know.”
The majority group Messina Protagonista (Paolo Alibrandi, Antonio Bonfiglio and Alessandro La Cava) responded: «The motion was rejected not due to prejudice, but for a much simpler reason: the politics of announcements cannot replace the concreteness of the proposals». In the commission, where there was extensive discussion also in the presence of ATM leaders, the councilor attributed the task of financing the initiative to the Municipality, in the Council he changed his version, calling ATM into question. More than a strategy, a change of direction without even consulting the navigator. And the real news is that the Democratic Party also voted in favor of the Scurria motion, the same Democratic Party that in Rome says that free maintenance takes money away from maintenance. In the meantime, Messina has moved forward, today’s public transport is not what it was 15 years ago and the citizens know it well: punctuality, investments, redevelopment of structures, free transport for students, discounts dedicated to people with disabilities, MoveMe subscription, thousands of subsidized passes in the restricted traffic zones. This is the difference between making propaganda and building public policies – conclude the councilors -: on the one hand a spot proposal, on the other structural investments”.
The Scurria Mayor-Participation council group intervenes on the topic with a note

“There are no resources for the citizens, but for the participatory system, yes? There must be clarity on appointments, compensation and public money. Messina Protagonista’s response to our proposal to make public transport free for a month at Christmas demonstrates, once again, how distant this majority is from the real problems of the people of Messina.

While many families struggle to make ends meet, with increasingly expensive bills, groceries and fuel, a concrete support measure is dismissed as propaganda. Evidently we don’t understand how much even a small saving can make a difference in people’s daily lives. But if we talk about public money, we would like the same attention to be paid to the costs of subsidiaries, the compensation of general managers, the allowances of mayors and councilors and the appointment system.

In 2018 Cateno De Luca announced the liquidation of the investee companies and even the elimination of the figure of the general director of Palazzo Zanca. Today the subsidiaries have become six and there are as many general management figures, with compensation of around 130 thousand euros per year each. Meanwhile, municipal administrators’ compensation has also reached record levels.

From the promises of cost reduction we have arrived at a multiplication of companies, tasks and expenses for government bodies. Furthermore, for too long, the same protagonists have found themselves at the top of various public companies. A system that fuels the suspicion of a salary factory, with tasks that always seem to revolve around the usual suspects.

Why are public selections announced if the same people always seem to fill certain positions? What criteria are adopted and how much do these choices cost citizens? The subsidiaries belong to the community, not to politics. We need transparency, meritocracy and accountability, not armchairs that change companies but seem to remain in the same hands.

As for ATM, the profits of around 11 million euros mentioned in our motion are real. We have proposed concrete help to families. The majority rejected it without demonstrating why it was impossible to implement. The real priority should be only one: using public resources in the interests of citizens. Because people come before seats and the needs of the city come before the interests of the apparatus.”

Digital Edition
From the Gazzetta del Sud on newsstands

Find out more in the digital edition

To read everything, buy the newspaper
or download the digital version.

Read the digital edition